Apple is in trouble because one of their big bosses, Phil Schiller, said he doesn't know if the App Store makes money. He also said they don't write down what they talk about in meetings. This happened during a court case where people are saying Apple isn't being fair with its app store rules. The reason for this might be because of Steve Jobs, who started Apple and told everyone not to write down their meeting notes. Read from source...
1. The headline is misleading and sensationalized: "Top Apple Exec Points To Steve Jobs Era For Lack Of Meeting Records, Casts Doubt On App Store's Profitability". It implies that Schiller directly linked the lack of meeting records to questioning the profitability of the App Store, which is not entirely accurate. He only mentioned that he was unsure if the App Store was profitable and that minutes were not recorded for senior executive meetings.
2. The article presents a one-sided narrative: It focuses on Schiller's testimony in an antitrust case against Apple, but does not mention any counterarguments or alternative perspectives from Apple or Epic Games. This creates a biased impression of the situation and does not provide a balanced view of the issue.
3. The article uses emotional language: Words like "admitted", "revelation", and "uncertain" suggest that Schiller's testimony is shocking or scandalous, when in reality it may be just another piece of evidence in an ongoing legal dispute. This inflames the reader's emotions and distracts from a rational analysis of the situation.
4. The article introduces irrelevant details: The mention of Steve Jobs' 1997 directive about taking meeting notes is not directly related to the profitability or antitrust issues of the App Store. It serves as a way to create a connection with Apple's past and its late co-founder, but does not contribute to understanding the current situation or challenges facing the company.
5. The article lacks critical thinking: It fails to question Schiller's statements or examine the assumptions behind his claims. For example, it does not challenge why profit is not a specific financial metric that he focuses on, or whether the metrics used by Apple are reliable and relevant for measuring the App Store's performance and impact on developers and consumers.
Neutral
Summary:
Phil Schiller, a top Apple executive, admitted in court that he is unsure if the App Store is profitable. He also revealed that Apple does not record minutes of meetings between senior executives due to a directive from Steve Jobs in 1997. This testimony comes amidst a global debate about Apple's App Store policies and legal challenges against the company.