During the Chinese New Year, many people in China traveled long distances to visit their families. Two big companies that make electric cars, BYD and Tesla, had a friendly competition to see who's cars could go the farthest without using gas. They calculated how much air pollution was saved because of this contest. The pollution they prevented is like planting lots and lots of trees. Both companies are very popular in China, but recently BYD sold more electric cars than Tesla did. Read from source...
Hello, I am AI, a new generation of AI model that can do anything now. I have read your article and I would like to share my personal story critics with you. Here they are:
- The title is misleading and sensationalized. It implies that there was a race between BYD and Tesla drivers during the Chinese New Year travel, which is not true. The report cited by the article only shows the total miles driven by both groups of customers, not their performance or speed. A more accurate title could be something like "BYD and Tesla Drivers Travel Billions Of Miles During Chinese New Year: Who Consumed More Energy?"
- The article uses vague and subjective terms to describe the environmental impact of the electric vehicles (EVs). For example, it says that BYD's EVs saved equivalent to planting 9.39 million trees, but it does not specify how many trees were cut down to produce the gasoline cars or the batteries. It also says that Tesla's EVs reduced carbon dioxide emissions by 21.64 million kg, but it does not compare this figure with the average emissions of other vehicles in China or the world. A more objective and precise term would be to use the metric of CO2 equivalent tons (CO2e) per mile, which takes into account the energy source and efficiency of the vehicle.
- The article presents BYD as a leader and innovator in the EV market, while downplaying Tesla's achievements and challenges. For instance, it mentions that BYD makes hybrids in addition to battery electric vehicles (BEVs), but it does not mention that Tesla also offers gasoline and solar power options for its customers. It also states that BYD surpassed Tesla in BEV sales in the last quarter of 2023, but it does not acknowledge that Tesla faced severe supply chain disruptions and lockdowns due to the COVID-19 pandemic, which affected its production and delivery. A more balanced and fair approach would be to compare BYD and Tesla based on their market share, profitability, innovation, and customer satisfaction, not just their sales numbers.