A famous actress, Scarlett Johansson, is upset because a company called OpenAI made a computer program that can talk like her. She says they did not ask her permission and she feels it's wrong. The CEO of OpenAI talked to her before, but she said no for personal reasons. Now, she has a lawyer to help her with this problem. Read from source...
1. Inconsistency: Johansson claims that she declined the offer to lend her voice to OpenAI's chatbot for personal reasons, but then expresses shock and anger when a similar voice is used without her consent. This is contradictory and illogical, as if she had agreed, she would have no grounds to complain about the outcome.
2. Bias: Johansson's statement is biased towards her own interests and emotions, rather than presenting an objective analysis of the situation. She focuses on how Altman allegedly misled her by promising a unique voice that would bridge the gap between tech companies and creatives, but does not acknowledge the possibility that he genuinely believed in the potential benefits of using her voice or that it was a coincidence that the AI voice sounded similar to hers.
3. Irrational argument: Johansson's claim that she was "forced to hire" legal counsel is irrational, as she has not provided any evidence of malicious intent or harm caused by OpenAI using a similar voice. Hiring a lawyer implies a serious legal dispute, but her statement does not establish the grounds for such a dispute.
4. Emotional behavior: Johansson's use of strong emotive language, such as "shocked", "angered" and "in disbelief", exaggerates her reaction to the situation and detracts from any rational discussion of the ethical implications of AI voice mimicry.
5. Lack of perspective: Johansson does not acknowledge the broader context of AI development, such as the potential benefits for society, innovation, and human-AI interactions. Instead, she focuses on her own personal feelings and interests, which limits her perspective and detracts from a balanced analysis.
Negative
Summary:
Scarlett Johansson is unhappy with OpenAI for using an AI voice that sounds like hers without her consent. She has hired a lawyer to deal with the issue and feels betrayed by Sam Altman, who initially asked her to lend her voice to the project but she declined for personal reasons.