Alright, imagine you have a really cool smartphone, the newest Apple iPhone. You love it and use it every day. Now, the company that makes these phones, called Apple, wants to make sure you always want the newest one. But lately, not many people are buying new ones because their current phones are still working well.

So, Apple is thinking of making some really special new iPhones with super cool features like a bigger screen or new games, so you'll be excited to buy them again. They're also trying to make phones that last longer and are more fun to use, so you can enjoy having one for even longer.

And because they're working on these new ideas, Apple's stock – which is like a special certificate that shows you own a tiny part of the company – might go up in price if people think those new iPhones will sell really well. Right now, some smart people who follow stocks closely think it might happen!

That's why we're talking about this: because it's interesting to think about what Apple is doing and how it could affect their stocks. It's like when you build a cool LEGO creation and you want all your friends to come see it – if lots of them do, then maybe more people will buy the same LEGO set! Read from source...

I have read the provided text, which appears to be a news article from Benzinga about Apple exploring new product innovations. However, without specific points or arguments presented by "DAN" (the alleged critic), it is not possible for me to evaluate or respond to their criticisms regarding inconsistencies, biases, irrational arguments, or emotional behavior in this particular text.

To provide a helpful response, I would need more context or specific examples from the critic's perspective. If you can provide that information, I'll do my best to address the concerns and facilitate an informed conversation around the topic.

Positive

Here are the aspects of the article that contribute to its positive sentiment:

1. **Innovative Products**: The article discusses Apple's plans to introduce new products like a thinner iPhone (iPhone 17 "Air"), a foldable iPad by 2028, and a 18.8-inch foldable iPad, which can reignite consumer interest.

2. **Growing Market Share**: Apple has recently seen growth in its smartphone sales, regaining the second spot in China's market with a 15.6% share. It also surpassed analyst projections for revenue in its fiscal fourth quarter.

3. **Stock Performance**: The company's stock has increased by 33.66% year-to-date, and analysts predict further upside of around 12%.

These points suggest that Apple is not just maintaining but actually growing and innovating, which contributes to the positive sentiment in the article.