A famous man named Steve Jobs, who helped create Apple, said that having a great idea is only the beginning of making something amazing. He believed that working together with a team makes the ideas even better and creates awesome products. Elon Musk, another smart person who made Tesla cars, agreed with him. They both think it's important to work hard as a group to make good things happen. Read from source...
- The article title is misleading and clickbaity, as it implies that Elon Musk reacted to a recent clip of Steve Jobs, when in fact the original interview with Jobs was from 1995, almost two decades before Musk's comment.
- The author uses vague terms like "a very serious disease" and "it" to refer to John Sculley without providing any context or explanation for what he did wrong or how it affected Apple. This creates confusion and makes the reader question the credibility of the source.
- The author also fails to mention that Jobs returned to Apple not only as an advisor, but also as the interim CEO, which is a more significant role than simply being part of the team. This omission weakens the comparison between Musk and Jobs, as it suggests that Jobs had less influence on Apple's products after his return than he actually did.
- The author uses quotations from Jobs to support his claim that ideas are not enough, but does not provide any evidence or examples of how Tesla or SpaceX have successfully turned their ideas into great products. This makes the argument seem unbalanced and one-sided, as it only highlights Jobs' perspective without acknowledging Musk's achievements or challenges.
- The author ends with a vague reference to "a part of" without completing the sentence or explaining what that part is. This leaves the reader hanging and unsatisfied, as they are not sure what the point of the article was or how it relates to them.
Positive
Explanation: The article discusses the agreement between Elon Musk and Steve Jobs on the importance of teamwork in creating great products. It highlights their views on how ideas evolve during the product development process and how a good leader should not rely solely on having great ideas, but also on implementing them effectively through collaboration. The overall tone of the article is positive as it portrays both Musk and Jobs as successful leaders who value teamwork and craftsmanship in their respective fields.